Alberta's highest court has dealt a crushing blow to business owners hoping to recover losses from pandemic-era public health restrictions, overturning a lower court's approval of a major class-action lawsuit.
In a decisive Friday ruling, the Alberta Court of Appeal found the case is "bound to fail" — ending hopes for compensation among restaurants, gyms, and other businesses that shuttered or faced operational limits during COVID-19 lockdowns.
The Legal Clash
The lawsuit, led by gym operator Rebecca Ingram and Whistle Stop Cafe owner Christopher Scott, sought damages from the Alberta government over financial losses tied to pandemic closures. Lawyer Jeffrey Rath filed the case after a landmark 2023 court decision found that Alberta's health orders had violated the Public Health Act.
That earlier ruling determined that while the chief medical officer of health made recommendations, it was cabinet and government committees — not health officials — who wielded final decision-making power. The orders were nonetheless found to be constitutional.
"If the identical orders had been issued by the Chief Medical Officer, there would be no negligent act and no claim," the appeal panel wrote in its 17-page decision.
Where It Falls Apart
The appeal court's three-judge panel rejected the argument that procedural flaws in how orders were issued should trigger government liability for business losses. The judges ruled that Rath's lawsuit failed to establish a direct causal link between the procedural defect and actual injury to affected businesses.
"The class action pleadings fail to disclose causation — that the alleged procedural defect caused injury to the class members," the panel stated.
This finding represents a significant legal distinction: even if the process was flawed, that doesn't automatically mean the government owes compensation for pandemic-related business losses.
What Happens Now
The decision effectively ends the class-action route for compensation. Business owners who faced restrictions will have little legal recourse through Alberta's court system on these grounds.
Interestingly, Whistle Stop Cafe owner Scott had faced criminal charges for keeping his Mirror, Alberta restaurant open despite dining restrictions in January 2021. Those charges were stayed — suspended pending possible future prosecution — after the earlier court ruling about procedural violations, but they remain technically on the books.
For Alberta's business community, the ruling underscores the challenges of challenging government pandemic policies in court, even when technical legal violations are found.
This story is based on reporting from CBC Calgary and covers legal developments affecting Alberta business owners and pandemic policy decisions.
