Local

Campaign Sign Chaos: Alberta Municipalities Left Scrambling as Referendum Rules Remain Murky

With October's referendum just weeks away, Calgary and Edmonton officials say unclear provincial guidelines are creating enforcement confusion and headaches.

Campaign Sign Chaos: Alberta Municipalities Left Scrambling as Referendum Rules Remain Murky
(CBC Calgary / File)

Less than a month before Alberta's October referendum, municipal leaders across the province are expressing serious frustration over who actually has the power to enforce campaign sign rules — and nobody seems to have a clear answer.

The problem stems from changes to Alberta's Election Act, which stripped municipalities of their ability to create bylaws regulating where election signs can be placed or how large they can be. Instead, that authority now rests with the provincial government — except nobody can quite figure out where the buck stops.

Calgary says it no longer has authority to regulate referendum advertising unless signs create public safety hazards or damage infrastructure. The city has already faced controversy after a video circulated online Tuesday showing city workers removing referendum signs from roadsides. The city acknowledged some signs were removed in error and later returned, but promised to investigate the incident.

The pro-independence group Let Alberta Decide disputes this account, saying Calgary has not returned its signs and that they were placed lawfully.

"We Know This City Better Than Anyone"

"The combination of those two things actually shows the value that municipalities can bring to something like this, because nobody knows this municipality better than us," Calgary Councillor Nathaniel Schmidt told reporters. "We work on the ground here directly with citizens every day. By removing that layer of regulation and enforcement to a higher level that maybe has less of that direct contact, then we can see what's happening now where there's less certainty around how things work."

Schmidt also flagged a troubling side effect: an increase in sign vandalism as the referendum approaches. Without clear municipal enforcement powers, cities say they're hamstrung in addressing property damage and public space conflicts.

Edmonton attempted to resolve some confusion by amending its Public Spaces Bylaw in March, removing provisions specifically tied to election signs following the provincial changes. However, the bylaw still contains general provisions about sign placement and public space use — creating an unclear patchwork of rules.

Provincial Finger-Pointing

When asked which provincial body enforces election sign rules, the Alberta Justice Minister's office pointed to Elections Alberta. But Elections Alberta pushed back, saying it only has jurisdiction over the content of signs and advertisements, not their placement, size, or removal when damaged.

Elections Alberta directed inquiries about sign size and placement back to the Alberta government — creating what critics call a regulatory dead zone.

The Justice Minister's office declined to issue a formal statement but told CBC News that rules do exist for sign placement and size on provincial highways.

Dylan Bressey, president of Alberta Municipalities, warned that the lack of clear regulations is creating a genuine governance crisis at the municipal level.

"Municipal councils and mayors don't know what the rules currently are," Bressey said. "This is creating confusion for everyone — from residents wanting to display signs to city staff trying to enforce basic public order."

With just weeks until Albertans head to the polls for the referendum, municipal leaders are calling for urgent clarification from the provincial government to establish clear, enforceable standards for campaign signage.

This story was originally reported by CBC Calgary's Kyra Thompson, Andrew Jeffrey, and Amir Said.

Share this story