Calgary Mayor Jeromy Farkas is pushing back hard against Alberta's controversial new bike lane legislation, saying the bill tabled this week doesn't match promises made by Premier Danielle Smith's office.
The proposed law would hand Transportation Minister Devin Dreeshen sweeping power to order municipalities to rip out bike lanes deemed problematic. But there's a catch—as written, cities would have to cover the removal costs, something Farkas says is a dealbreaker.
"My understanding and speaking with the premier's office is that was a mistake," Farkas told reporters Friday outside Calgary city council chambers. "The provincial government will fully pay for any change orders that are required. The premier's office has told me that under no circumstances will municipalities be paying for this and I take that to the bank."
The move signals growing tension between Alberta's provincial government and major cities over transportation policy. Edmonton and Calgary have invested heavily in cycling infrastructure over the past decade, with bike lanes woven through key corridors across both cities.
What the Bill Actually Says
Bill 43, introduced Thursday, would essentially ban bike lanes that slow traffic on busy routes unless the province specifically approves them. It gives the minister authority to order removal of existing lanes deemed problematic—citing concerns about reduced road capacity, lost parking, increased congestion, and potential obstacles for emergency vehicles.
Dreeshen has argued the province shouldn't shoulder the financial burden, noting that Edmonton and Calgary have dedicated cycling budgets while the provincial government does not. He suggested the most cost-effective approach would be removing bike lanes during scheduled road maintenance in the same locations.
But the transportation ministry has notably avoided directly responding to Farkas's claims about promised amendments. In a statement, Dreeshen said the government wants "better collaboration" with cities on transportation decisions.
The Price Tag Problem
The cost of compliance could be staggering. Internal Edmonton emails have suggested removing the city's existing bike lanes could run at least $150 million—a massive unfunded liability if downloaded to municipalities.
Farkas characterized the current bill language as a "premature draft version" that doesn't reflect the actual deal negotiated with the province. He expects revisions will clarify that Alberta, not cities, will cover removal expenses.
Albertans have been vocal about bike lanes in recent months. When the provincial government invited public complaints about cycling infrastructure, thousands of residents responded, though opinions remain deeply divided between those viewing bike lanes as essential urban planning and those seeing them as obstacles to vehicle traffic.
Originally reported by CBC Edmonton
