Four years after their autistic son was handcuffed at a St. Albert playground and detained in RCMP custody, Laura Hawthorne and Aaron Krause are running out of patience.
Ryley Bauman was just 16 in October 2022 when officers arrested him at a playground, mistaking the non-verbal teenager—who functions at a seven-year-old level—for an intoxicated adult. What followed was a traumatic detention that left lasting scars on the entire family.
"They can hide behind paperwork and blow off deadlines and it's been over four years and we've just watched Ryley deteriorate," Hawthorne told CBC News, her frustration evident. "I'm never going to let go of this."
A System in Crisis: Questions About Police Training and Accountability
According to an earlier Alberta watchdog investigation, Bauman repeatedly harmed himself while in custody, was held down by officers, and was sedated before being taken to hospital. It took RCMP days to learn the teenager had been reported missing by his family.
The RCMP Civilian Review and Complaints Commission (CRCC) launched its own inquiry to determine whether officers properly accommodated Bauman's disability and whether better training could help police distinguish neurological conditions from intoxication. Four years on, that report remains unpublished.
"Ryley deserves not just justice for what happened to him, but Ryley deserves changes inside of the RCMP's operating system," Krause said. "There shouldn't be a massive bureaucratic red-tape nightmare preventing an organization that is supposed to protect people from admitting that it made a mistake."
Systemic Delays Plague Investigation
CRCC officials blamed investigative delays and staffing shortages for the protracted review. The inquiry was paused for years while the Alberta Serious Incident Response Team (ASIRT) conducted its own separate investigation.
In March 2024, ASIRT concluded that charges of unlawful confinement and assault should be considered against the three arresting officers involved—yet the CRCC report that could recommend disciplinary action or policy changes remains locked away.
Krause characterized Canada's RCMP watchdog system as fundamentally flawed, describing it as "jawless" when it comes to holding officers accountable. The delay raises serious questions about whether oversight bodies can effectively protect vulnerable Albertans from police misconduct.
"When it comes to falling through the cracks, Ryley deserves more."
— Laura Hawthorne, Ryley's mother
For the Bauman family, the wait continues. With each passing month, their son's trauma deepens, and their faith in the system erodes further.
This article is based on reporting by CBC Edmonton. Read the full investigation at CBC News.
