The old hockey saying "Once an Oiler, Always an Oiler" rings hollow this May, with Edmonton's roster eliminated from playoff contention while three former Oilers are making noise on teams with legitimate Stanley Cup aspirations.
Taylor Hall, Brett Kulak, and Ryan McLeod have become key contributors for their respective clubs — with Hall and Kulak playing for Carolina and Colorado, the two franchises currently favoured to meet in the Stanley Cup Final.
Hall Thriving in Carolina
The 34-year-old Hall, who was infamously dealt to New Jersey in the "one-for-one" swap for Adam Larsson back in 2016, has found new life in Carolina. Playing on a dangerous line alongside Jackson Blake and Logan Stankoven, Hall is leading the Hurricanes in playoff scoring with 12 points through eight games, adding a team-leading +10 rating.
Despite scoring just two goals in 15 playoff games last season, Hall has elevated his game considerably in this year's push toward June. The veteran forward — who has worn the jersey of six different NHL teams since leaving Edmonton — now has a legitimate shot at claiming his first Stanley Cup and potentially earning the Conn Smythe Trophy as playoff MVP.
Kulak and McLeod Making Their Mark
Brett Kulak, the reliable defenceman who spent seasons anchoring Edmonton's back end, has become a critical piece for Colorado's championship-contending squad. Meanwhile, McLeod continues to contribute in a supporting role for his new organization.
Questions Linger in Edmonton
The success of these former Oilers raises uncomfortable questions about Edmonton's front office decisions during the Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl era. All three players were involved in trades that generated considerable controversy at the time.
With the team eliminated from playoff contention, speculation is already mounting about whether head coach Kris Knoblauch will remain behind the bench for the 2026-27 season — or if Edmonton's front office will seek new leadership as they attempt to build a winner around their generational talent.
This article is based on reporting from the Edmonton Journal.